February 19, 2015  ·  Lessig  · Reblogged from  Huffington Post

Imagine that when you plugged something into an electrical outlet, the outlet queried the device and demanded identification. Was it a Sony TV or Panasonic? Was it a Dell or an Apple? And then based on that identification, different levels of quality or reliability of electricity were served at different prices. No doubt such a regime would benefit utility companies. I’ve not yet met anyone who thinks it would benefit innovation. Thus, it would be something possibly good for network providers, but plainly bad for the market generally.

As I’ve watched the amazing progress that proponents of “network neutrality” have made, I’ve been astonished both by their success, and by how long this debate has been going on. I first drew the analogy to the electrical grid in testimony before John McCain’s subcommittee more than a dozen years ago. Mark Lemley and I tried to lay the issue out, as it applied to the then-raging battle over “open access,” almost 15 years ago. But now, thanks to the incredible work of many, including especially Marvin Ammori, Susan Crawford, Harold Feld (even from the old days), Barbara van Schewick, Kevin Werbach, and Tim Wu, the FCC has come around to recognize its crucial role in preserving the environment for innovation. If the order is as the order seems it will be, it will mark an extraordinary conversion by the chairman, and former industry lobbyist, of the FCC. Nixon went to China, Johnson passed the Civil Rights Acts, and Chairman Wheeler got us network neutrality.

Defenders of the status quo are now frantically filling the tubes with FUD about the FCC’s decision. But as you work through this FUD, keep one basic fact clear. Relative to practically every other comparable nation, America’s broadband sucks. Seriously, sucks. Even France beats us in cost and quality. And as the genius Yochai Benkler established in the monumental report by the Berkman Center commissioned by the FCC after Obama was elected, the single most important reason our broadband sucks is the sell-out regulatory strategy of the prior decade at least. Nations that imposed neutrality-like rules beat us, in cost and quality. They have more competition, faster growth, and better access. So for anyone remotely connected to reality-based policy making, it has been clear forever that America made a wrong turn in its regulatory strategy, and that we needed an about face.

The FCC’s likely action here is that about face. I’ve not seen the details. Those that have worry rightly that there are improvements that still need to be made. (Barbara van Schewick’s ex parte filing of yesterday raises some really important concerns.) But we’re in a place where the FCC has no incentives except to get it right. And if the community that has done the incredible work to carry this issue this far can focus on these final critical steps, we could well see a real victory here. Finally. (Though I still worry about the next step, as Susan Crawford has so terrifyingly described.)

The president deserves credit for pressing this issue again. Chairman Wheeler deserves real credit for looking carefully at the facts, and recognizing the truth in what the president was pressing. Title-II-light is the right regulatory home. Unlike the old days with utility regulation, the FCC will not regulate rates, or impose tariffs, or undue administrative burdens. A clear regulatory commitment will set the direction for investment and innovation — in fast, cheap broadband (something much of the world has had, but the U.S., not so much), and continued and renewed permission-free innovation.

For if the telephone companies that built the first broadband network (DSL) could discriminate, would Skype have happened? And if the cable companies that have built the second broadband network could discriminate, would YouTube have happened? The history in Internet innovation is the story of outsiders building a better mouse trap — kids, dropouts, and non-Americans, given a neutral platform to prove their ideas. It was neutral because it was built that way. If we’re to preserve that platform for innovation, we have to keep it that way, through whatever means possible.

Cross-posted from Lessig Blog.

(Original post on HuffPo)

  • mckirt

    I enjoyed your presentation on campaign financing and the analogy on Hong Kong and USA

    The .024 percentages shows how much vote does count …. we need campaign financing to root out the

    Superpacs.. and how they influence change ….. campaign reform must come from both sides

  • jeenarrohan

    For writing any kind of essay, there are mainly three parts. They are introduction, text/ paragraph, and the conclusion. Introduction part should have a brief description, don’t exceed a limit. Add a description about your topic in the introduction part. Then only the readers will get the idea about your topic. The next one is paragraph part; it may be brief or lengthy. The complete explanation about your essay topic can be added to the text part. Last the conclusion, in which you can conclude the topic.

  • ipaco
  • loansmob

    Net-neutrality is something that is seldom discussed, but is a topic that concerns the majority of the internet surfing population. It involves giving preference to certain sites while throttling the rest. It is essential that internet remain a neutral venue, otherwise it will not provide a fair opportunity to startups. Consider how facebook would have developed if it was throttled by network providers. This is where FCC has got it right. To know more about upcoming companies which have benefited from net neutrality, you can visit http://loansmob.com/

  • yiwu market

    thanks for share! I like your blog, Good Job!
    yiwu agent

  • http://www.essays-shark.net Tabitha Lafleur

    Thank you for sharing this info.Nice blog.Also,you can visit http://www.essays-shark.net mine.There you can order any needful paper or ask for professional help

  • Eduard Armen

    Interesting topic shown here, i am now working on it regularly here and would say keep the future posts like this continuously. Pass4sure 300-135 PDF

  • http://www.fresh-essay.com CaraRotten

    I’m finding myself very fond of reading your post, so I am highly engaged into browsing over it.I am not that creative but thank you, now I have something to follow.Also I want recommend everyone most popular service for all students http://fresh-essay.com!

  • Cara

    Great article I like it so much. Thanks

  • Cara

    Great content It really happens to me at the very right time Thanks for the article so much. It helps many people to grow and things have been going so well in the command of the article.


  • https://dianabolbulk.com/ Dianabolbulk

    Great article I like it so much.

  • https://dianabolbulk.com/ Dianabolbulk

    Thanks for bringing in this kind of article for your viewer. I enjoyed it very much keep it up. as you described about the right thing about net neutrality and the fcc is so cool. I am here to make my presence over in you web portal dianabolbulk I am glad that I found this article.

  • Marko Djelic

    Alter the default wireless network name. In most cases the ssid is equivalent to the wireless router maker brand which can help the unexpected person easily find the default router IP, username and password. If there’s an opportunity available to stop delivering the ssid or network name, select this on top of that.

  • Lauren Connor

    Net neutrality is the topic on which debated by the social media lovers in various countries as it is the principle that Internet service providers should allow access to all content and applications nevertheless of the source, and without favouring or blocking particular products or websites. And I have heard from the students who have been taking dissertation writing help from me as I am dissertation tutor & consultant at Quality Dissertation – http://www.qualitydissertation.co.uk that In India, There were no laws governing net neutrality in India before August 2015 after government has ran online campaign on social media for Net neutrality for applying Net neutrality Law. And In February 2016, the country has welcomed by the all the Indian.

  • phung

    Đặt Hoa chia buồn giá rẻ – mua hoa chia buồn. Điện hoa đẹp có hàng trăm mẫu hoa tươi khác nhau đáp ứng được nhu cầu chọn và mua của khách hàng, hoa chia buồn giá rẻ của chúng tôi với hoa tươi chất lượng với sự hài lòng của khách hàng, chúng tôi đáp ứng tối nhất nhu cầu mua hoa chia buồn cho mọi khách hàng, tư vấn và chọn mua mẫu hoa chia buồn ưng ý nhất. Đặt Hoa chia buồn giá rẻ – mua hoa tang lễ đẹp TPHCM. 018. Hoa Tươi Shop còn dạng các thể loại hoa tươi như hoa valentine, hoa bó đẹp, hoa khai trương…Vòng hoa chia buồn giá rẻ – hoa tang lễ đẹp TPHCM. Shop hoa TPHCM có hàng trăm mẫu hoa tươi khác nhau đáp ứng được nhu cầu chọn và mua của khách hàng, hoa tang lễ giá rẻ của chúng tôi với hoa tươi chất lượng với sự hài lòng của khách hàng, chúng tôi đáp ứng tối nhất nhu cầu mua hoa chia buồn cho mọi khách hàng Shop hoa tuoi TPHCM cảm thông sẻ chia với những sản phẩm hoa tuoi đẹp nhất được kết thành vòng hoa tang lễ đẹp độc đáo gửi đến người đã khuất hoa tang le

  • phung

    hoa khai truong hay còn gọi là hoa chúc mừng dùng trong các sự kiện, dịp lễ quan trọng của cá nhân, tổ chức tập thể như mừng khai trương công ty, cửa hàng công sở, mua hoa gì để gửi tặng bạn bè đồng nghiệp, đối tác nhân dịp họ khai trương cửa hàng, công ty, tổ chức các sự kiện qua trọng. Hãy liên hệ với chúng tôi, với gần như đầy đủ các thể loại hoa tươi đặc biệt hoa chúc mừng khai trương cửa hàng. Khách hàng có nhu cầu mua hoa khai trương sẽ được đội ngũ nhân viên phục vụ tận tình với dịch vụ hoa tươi đẹp nhất chuyên nghiệp, chất lượng, nhanh chóng, giá rẻ. Shop hoa tươi chúng tôi luôn lấy khách hàng làm trung tâm của sự phục vụ. Shop hoa đẹp, hoa chúc mừng khai trương cửa hàng. Ngoài hoa chúc mừng khai trương Hoa Tươi Shop còn rất dạng các sản phẩm hoa tuoi như hoa chia buon, hoa valentine, hoa tặng mẹ, hoa tặng thầy cô, hoa hoa tặng người yêu…Trong những dịp lễ kỹ niệm, lễ khởi công hay ngày khai trương chúc mừng, khác hàng dễ dàng lựa chọn với hàng trăm mẫu hoa tươi đẹp nhất tuy thuộc thể loại hoa khách nhau mà sự lựa chọn cũng đa dạng theo. Shop hoa tuoi chúng tôi luôn lấy khách hàng làm trung tâm của sự phục vụ. Shop hoa đẹp, mua hoa khai trương giá rẻ – hoa chúc mừng khai trương TPHCM

  • Julia Roberts

    I am glad to reach to your website, however our website also offer similar content and we would definitely like to recommend your website to our friends.HND Assignment Help
    Assignment Help in UK
    Check out our link http://www.hndassignmenthelp.co.uk

  • Henny Lyn

    This is really very nice blog and so informative.

  • NeviChen

    Thanks for posting, this is really amazing.
    BandarQQ Online

  • Jeslyn Aritama
  • graceben

    Students are always fear to approach the writing task independently. Lack of confidence is because of lack of knowledge.Essay writing service reviews can help students to improve knowledge and skill through continous participation. https://essaywriting-uk.co.uk/

  • charles winget

    The hacking tool that you have been waiting for is here NBA 2K17 XBOX ONE With our online hacking tool, you can easily generate the unlimited number of virtual currencies into your account.

  • https://www.withoutverification.com Paul Stalks

    Instagram is a great source for both small and big businesses to advertise their products and attract more traffic. With enough Instagram followers, your business will grow faster than anticipated. If you are looking for a reliable, trusted, and professional service that offers free Instagram likes and followers to prospective clients, then WithoutVerification is the place to visit.

  • charles winget

    Want to download any game or software related to PlayStation, it is the time when the user needs to spend money in buying these games or software, So here comes the role of these codes(PSN Codes) which helps in availing discount, and spend lesser while purchasing or downloading any stuff related to PlayStation. There is no need to worry about how to get these PSN codes, just visit the link FREE PSN CODES 2017 mentioned here and all will be done with ease. These PSN codes are very easy to use and are very helpful in getting the deals done in more simpler and cheaper way.

  • Sunil

    Super Bowl 52 is Sunday, Feb. 4, 2018 at U.S. Bank Stadium (home of the Minnesota Vikings) in Minneapolis, Minn. The Twin Cities last played host to the Big Game 26 years ago, when Washington beat Buffalo 37-24 at the Metrodome in Super Bowl XXVI. The game will be broadcast on NBC.

    Super Bowl 2018 telecast
    super bowl 2018 live updates
    NFL Playoffs live stream

  • Bivathu

    Find the best selection and best prices for Super Bowl tickets at TicketCity – your trusted ticket source for 27+ years! 100% Guaranteed Super Bowl Tickets.
    Super Bowl 2018 schedule
    super bowl live online
    NFL Playoffs live stream
    NFL super bowl 52 streams
    Super Bowl online