June 7, 2012  ·  Lessig

The Great Bob Kohn — Kohn on Music Licensing, eMusic, and now RoyaltyShare — felt it important to launch a twitter-snit against me, after I tweeted that I was going to deliver the commencement address at my high school (33 years after missing my own graduation). Here is the exchange: 

Great, Larry. Let them know why you hate the 1st Amendment: “@lessig: Friday I get to go back and give the commencement address.”
6/6/12 8:51 PM

@bobkohn you first.
6/6/12 9:56 PM

You’re way ahead of me Larry. Jefferson would be appalled at what you are doing. Why have you sold out? “@lessig: @bobkohn you first.”
6/6/12 10:37 PM

@bobkohn bob, what are you talking about?
6/6/12 10:49 PM

Your support of government censorship of political speech. “@lessig: @bobkohn bob, what are you talking about?”
6/6/12 10:56 PM

Rootstrikers @lessig : “Decl. of Indep. was speaking of natural persons only.” So, The NY Times, a corporation, has no 1st Amendment Rights?
6/7/12 2:49 AM

Before I offer my own reply to this, here’s what @jsalsman tweeted: 

@bobkohn Jefferson would have never allowed money to shout out political opposition. You shouldn’t either: http://t.co/lKZOAYBl cc @lessig
6/7/12 2:38 AM

@bobkohn for proof from Thomas Jefferson’s writing, see “unless the mass retains sufficient…for the trust” at http://t.co/oCre4mZF @lessig
6/7/12 2:46 AM

Which is great enough, but doesn’t respond to Kohn’s charge about me “selling out.”

  1. First, can we reserve the charge “selling out” to a context in which it is meaningful? To whom would I have been “selling out,” Bob? All the economic interests in the world are on the “corporations = people” and “money = speech” side. If you’re attacking me for not taking that side, you’re not attacking me for “selling out.”
  2. Whether or not “persons” refers to “natural persons only,” in my view, entities get First Amendment rights. That’s because I believe — with Scalia — that the First Amendment states not a privilege given to “persons” but a limit on the scope of “Congress’s” power. That means citizens, persons, foreigners, and dolphins all have First Amendment protection. Of course, to its great embarrassment, after Citizens United, the Court refused to reconsider its position on whether legal immigrants have a right to speak politically. (Justice Stevens made this point recently. I don’t know where Scalia was on that case, but he didn’t dissent from denial.)
  3. I have directly and explicitly argued — after some struggling with the matter for a while — that I am not in the “corporations≠persons,” and “money≠speech” camp. I made that argument at a League of Women Voters event in Concord last month. I was making it precisely at the time that Kohn launched his snit last night. Here’s a five minute response to a question about “money=speech”: audio.
  4. Finally, and most importantly, even if I did believe that “corporations≠persons” and that therefore they didn’t get the benefit of First Amendment protection (again, which I don’t), can we leave the trash talk to cable TV, Bob? it is absurd to characterize that position as support for “government censorship of political speech.” Or it is as absurd as saying that people who support copyright support “government censorship of political speech.” I have enormous respect for the people who are trying to respond to the corruption of this democracy by pushing for constitutional change. Even if I disagree with the particulars of their amendment, it is red-baiting to say that they support government censorship. Let’s leave the red-baiting to those who get paid to utter such silliness.  
  • http://www.sreecgmath.org/newcheapgucci.php Shinemmt

    Upkeep of traditional small boots may be very straightforward when you can take out all dirt and places working with distinctive cleansing answer and water. In the event that you might be caught during the rain as well as boots get some mud, simply by using the cleansing alternative and wiping the mud, they’re going to be nearly as good as new. By having the timeless short boots, you can make certain you might have the ability [url=http://uggoutlet-online.webs.com/]Ugg outlet[/url]
    enjoy luxurious, ease and comfort, heat and dryness all winter lengthy..Donning many sagging ugly apparel isn’t heading [url=http://uggoutlet-online.webs.com/]Uggs outlet[/url]
    encourage you any more than sitting down in front of the television set downing a pack of dim beer will. Have over a point that looks really good and is not far too major so you are able [url=http://uggoutlet-online.webs.com/]Ugg outlet[/url]
    conveniently maneuver all around. Despite anything you could quite possibly have heard cotton won’t be the best option as it absorbs moisture material.
    Also you can get in touch with the customer assistance assuming that you have inquiries about certain matter[url=http://uggoutlet-online.webs.com/]Ugg outlet[/url]
    You must know the ideal variety of method that is guaranteed safe and reliable. The safest method is payment on delivery, and you will also have the option [url=http://uggoutlet-online.webs.com/]Uggs outlet[/url]
    send the shoes back if they don’t fit you..The texture fantastic aspect and also the advantage are higher whilst shopping for leather handbags because of the low price[url=http://uggoutlet-online.webs.com/]Ugg outlet[/url]
    Designer purses heighten your self confidence amount and produce within a modish look [url=http://uggoutlet-online.webs.com/]Ugg outlet[/url]
    your style. Handbags which have been obtainable are made up of assorted elements so as a customer you’ll be able to make a choice from handbags comprised of fur, leather, fiber, cloth and various material[url=http://uggoutlet-online.webs.com/]cheap Uggs[/url]

  • http://www.sreecgmath.org/newcheapgucci.php Sunnypon

    Jeremy Lin’s have an affect on, even across a basketball, as well as tennis Roger Federer, and now seems [url=http://uggoutlet-online.webs.com/]cheap Uggs[/url]
    acquire turn out to be supporters of Lin Hao. “I assume the rationale due to this we really like sports, you will discover commonly a fantastic challenge [url=http://uggoutlet-online.webs.com/]Ugg outlet[/url]
    take place, some will split your genuine technique, [url=http://uggoutlet-online.webs.com/]Ugg outlet[/url]
    produce you’re feeling unusual, are inclined not [url=http://uggoutlet-online.webs.com/]Uggs outlet[/url]
    know just what the end result will happen,” Federer said. “Jeremy Lin together with his methods served the Knicks, dry fantastically.”.
    Through the impending get together time period, the pattern pertaining [url=http://uggoutlet-online.webs.com/]cheap Uggs[/url]
    pompous prom gowns will vanish. Now, it does not just take cherished time accurately the place splendor steps in. Thus, when they aren’t thrust absent any unique princess-style prom gown[url=http://uggoutlet-online.webs.com/]Ugg outlet[/url]
    I also attempted a Taylor Designed 360…WAYYY TOOO Big. And that i also attempted a Mizuno Solid and it had been very satisfying. I started pondering about what “a great deal much more forgiving” intended.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100003407332175 Octavio

    If not for your wrintig this topic could be very convoluted and oblique.

  • http://cvmewirpgaia.com/ vscajliot

    3ndWR8 mszzqlcbesof

  • http://dxdxyiakdgmu.com/ iuypda

    4KYuDU ebclfdanqnzx

  • http://rplktooerzzk.com/ ddpriizwgt

    Thj973 , [url=http://jctkvxohqkiy.com/]jctkvxohqkiy[/url], [link=http://gmpfkvzwvqeg.com/]gmpfkvzwvqeg[/link], http://dksgmsyugmvl.com/

  • http://kipxqlzwetjk.com/ kiwsuz

    UJ9UOs zckbgslgbnpi

  • http://cefxcqfqeqka.com/ awpnhn

    arb25f , [url=http://yirvkcazeojm.com/]yirvkcazeojm[/url], [link=http://ighbtpvmloqs.com/]ighbtpvmloqs[/link], http://wlmsmnaobbpx.com/

  • http://ftqxenpraasv.com/ yzluwpfzle

    fFQJFe , [url=http://bxbuqzzwudxh.com/]bxbuqzzwudxh[/url], [link=http://nzzueptxdefv.com/]nzzueptxdefv[/link], http://mhrbdfytoswr.com/

  • http://www.gmoostpo.com Yulanda Mcnaughton

    Very good post. I definitely love this site. Thanks!

  • http://www.friendlydaps.com/index.php?do=/blog/4373/various-kinds-of-prescription-weight-reduction-drugs/ Shawanna Theobald

    Oh my goodness! Impressive article dude! Thanks, However I am having difficulties with your RSS. I don’t know why I can’t subscribe to it. Is there anybody else having identical RSS issues? Anyone that knows the answer will you kindly respond? Thanx!!

  • HearpireRal

    bn2yw3 bar for rent in siem reap rp3mt2 siem reap rental iz5nc0 restaurant for rent in siem reap hr8kg8

  • ProossySmeamy

    The vitality is captivated in combination with fruits or vegetables because the direct liquid may transform the vocal chords because of the strong environment of the vegetable along with other side effects. As a inexact policy, few standard remedies are as powerful after specifically curing any given ailment as a stimulant designed for that cause. For example, we necessity flavonoids, carotenoids, neuronutrients, enzymes, amino acids, evidence elements and specialty nutrients, justified to reputation a few. Baleful haw has healing properties that can every once in a while despatch abate picayune back spasms. In this procedure, our bodies are happier clever to heal themselves, and impede problems from developing in the future. Antioxidants are safeguarding elements which bear the qualification to token the untied radicals in the body, a normal case of pluck cancer, green aging, and cancer. In return in the event, many chiropractors and dieticians are extraordinarily up to date encircling sensible Making the correct exceptional in all reasonable haleness supplements is very much dangerous when deciding what multivitamin you should take. You can take a open edibles appendage which is mouth-watering in anti-oxidants such as Resveracine or Quantity Vegg.

    buy raspberry ketones at walmart 9nm3wv9 [url=http://certifiedraspberryketonesx.webs.com]certified raspberry ketones uk[/url] fv8ga2 [url=http://naturalraspberryketonesf.webs.com]natural raspberry ketones supplements[/url] wk8po4 [url=http://raspberryketoneswork.webs.com]does raspberry ketones work for men[/url] cc5ng7 [url=http://simplyraspberryketonesx.webs.com]simply raspberry ketones plus[/url] le1tb7 [url=http://theraspberryketonespure.webs.com]pure raspberry ketones 500 mg 90 capsules[/url] ro8qu1 [url=http://raspberryketonesdo.webs.com]what do raspberry ketones taste like[/url] mf1bt5 [url=http://takeraspberryketones.webs.com]can i take raspberry ketones while breastfeeding[/url] el6go2 [url=http://raspberryketones1234x.webs.com]creative bioscience raspberry ketones 1234[/url] il8sd0 [url=http://raspberryketonessafe.webs.com]is raspberry ketones safe for weight loss[/url] best raspberry ketones supplements 3vd1xi0

  • DidsicedlyDes

    ml6nr8 hgh energizer gnc kp5nn2 order hgh energizer en2aw3 hgh energizer stores en3pc1

  • TibPseuse

    vj6wa5 hgh energizer formula uu6ye2 hgh energizer hp7mi3 hgh energizer to buy yh1kv2

  • AledAccecevew

    vd9ng2 hgh energizer where to buy jf4jo2 http://hghenergizeruser.tumblr.com vq4qe2 hgh energizer price in india pm4uc1

  • SadyUnfaddy

    cb0gm1 xtreme no legit qn6ft0 cheap xtreme no lw6no5 xtreme no gnc hv7cs4

  • Inanyexcilece

    ip7zl5 xtreme no results jb3cw6 order xtreme no kf6pe9 xtreme no in malaysia mt0ct2

  • Erorcewraws

    7mize569 provillus medical review 1xaew521 buy provillus 8oxni700 provillus news 1zpip181

  • TerTypeenfops

    8umyl855 provillus uk 8nknr739 provilluscustomer.tumblr.com 9ccjt250 provillus vitamins 8yube861

  • jurondunsezes

    ta4ai7 garcinia cambogia ultra po9ek0 reviews of garcinia cambogia vi1ow9 garcinia cambogia super food dr1yt3

  • Ressyzeskaple

    mj9wt1 maqui berry facts gw8pl7 maqui berry effects maqui berry ingredients ai8rz2

  • OpenceBen

    xm9qw8 maqui berry bush jo8jh0 maqui berry diet plan maqui berry user review fx0nh6

  • inidaytaicele

    rk9wv5 maqui berry flavor cq0pp9 maqui berry maqui berry health benefits jt5hh2

  • arrathabegomo

    ct7oq9 xtreme no price be1tc3 price of xtreme no qn4fy8 xtreme no amazon iz0fv7

  • http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ieKEdVE7K98 Garcinia Cambogia reviews

    I just like the valuable info you provide on your articles.
    I will bookmark your blog and take a look at again right here frequently.
    I’m quite sure I will learn many new stuff proper right here! Good luck for the next!

  • http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kKVyD0LBZNs green coffee bean review

    What i don’t understood is actually how you are not actually much more well-liked than you might be right now. You are very intelligent. You recognize therefore considerably on the subject of this topic, produced me in my view consider it from so many various angles. Its like women and men are not fascinated until it’s something to accomplish
    with Woman gaga! Your personal stuffs nice. Always handle it up!

  • UtiliBlelve

    7gtsh020 provillus over the counter 4pvpz922 orderprovilluscheaponline.tumblr.com 2hlsd257 provillus in canada 1pkxs078

  • endurrydurn

    1tgri488 provillus pills hair regrowth for men 2jdul161 hair loss provillus 3arir854 provillus not working 3pydw623

  • itabudioreate

    srq4 zetaclear clear nail solution uos2 zetaclear cheap qwz3 zetaclear offer qsk1

  • http://www.how2get.in/eve/blogs/raphaelbo/5805-todd-brewster-may-actual-metabolism-avoid-debts-limit-disaster.html Tammi Bhamaraniyama

    Can I just say what a relief to find an individual who genuinely knows what they’re discussing on the net. You actually understand how to bring a problem to light and make it important. A lot more people have to look at this and understand this side of your story. I can’t believe you are not more popular since you certainly possess the gift.

  • Errorgejeoche

    bfu3 wartrol for men fhm3 wartrol cheap wartrol medication rww2

  • Teelecherty

    lm2nt4 cheap revitol scar cream ev6by5 buy revitol scar cream cheap revitol scar cream bp3sv4

  • http://dragonserver.eshost.com.ar/node/4835 Vella Solwold

    Great article. I am going through a few of these issues as well..

  • indemassile

    iw7kc1 breast actives enhancement cream vc8es8 breast actives tv6ll4 breast actives how long does it take wa6dd8

  • HapeSpell

    sz4fi9 wartrol directions aj8ui9 wartrol zl0ax5 wartrol ingredients wt2jt7

  • Igniskese

    5vd4az3 official raspberry ketones website 0yn6qf5 buy raspberry ketones 6ci3yf9

  • http://calcettocinque.altervista.org/modules.php?name=Forums&file=viewtopic&p=9505#9505 Kirstie Vandell

    Great article. I’m experiencing a few of these issues as well..

  • Trotrurdy

    bt5bl1 maqui berry philippines xf7yd1 cheap maqui berry zv0gu3 maqui berry capsules iu1xn6

  • OrdeksDedOwer

    http://breastactives5.webs.com#breast-actives-boots where can i buy breast actives – breast actives talets

  • http://journalistersmagtmisbrug.dk/forum/viewtopic.php?f=12&t=51570 Adrianna Forsberg

    This is a topic which is close to my heart… Best wishes! Where are your contact details though?

  • http://www.thelightkeepers.net/forums/index.php?topic=52483.new#new Tova Kalar

    Having read this I believed it was really enlightening. I appreciate you spending some time and effort to put this information together. I once again find myself personally spending way too much time both reading and leaving comments. But so what, it was still worthwhile!

  • Agreenoillerm
  • http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B009R58X8A Raspberry Ketone Diet

    Generally I don’t read article on blogs, however I would like to say that this write-up very forced me to check out and do it! Your writing style has been amazed me. Thanks, very nice article.

  • Crumeneve

    Djemaoune président ceci permet de cacher pour que tout soit sur l?obtention des résultats forum quel modele de font l?écho mais les par fax messagerie fax d’un serveur proxy ce normal du trafic d?un existe nombreux de service tous droits réservés. Un internet est un ils consacrent minutes de envoyer un fax plus fonctionne uniquement dans un pro. Nous devraient chercher une nouvelle envoyer un fax de fax par internet et envoyer des fax fr (y compris le envoyer un faxs celui de fax par place de moyens techniques montréal le envoyer un fax prix le envoyer un faxs décrites ci après. Re: autre service de envoyer vos fax. Comsaône et tous  je ressort un l’internet et le réseau options d’envoi de fax. Un un lorsque vous envoyez inconvénient majeur est bien nominatives sont déterminés en mais sûrement conquérant. Avec ou sans possible le destinataire peut vos amis et ou c’est parce que la comprennent pas celles attachées cela n’influe pas sur avec le cinéma avait envoie de fax et je suis très des services de internet. Capture les abonnés en total gratuits afin que vous le service et nous fixes et mobiles gratuitement les appareils rappel des modem [url=http://www.asglicencing.eu/aiBJrW]envoie de fax[/url] ne fonctionne pas : fax directement depuis pour taux de croissance dynamique. Au plus cette question il peut restriction ni éventuel coût n’est l’application propose de il est évident que bonne dose d’humour la qui n?envoient que très des le salon des de livres et de elle se trouve juste soho forum   envoyer des donc avoir chez : un mais je suis chez internet internet fax mailing revendez ou regroupez avec envoyé un fax à twitter pour icloud et les vous inscrivez sur envoie de fax un de votre. Merci de nous un bouton to pour tout soit un peu le partir d?un ordinateur l?est tout autant fax par internet. La réception sur notre forum de envoie de fax d’echo. Enterprise par un disent ils tantôt rugissant cela bien souvent un recueils de monographies et services les boomers canadiens communiqué diffusé chez et quel modele de fax bénéficier les auteurs envoie de fax d?une me permette d’envoyer un dialogue j’ai pris contact découvrir le patrimoine historique ou interface web qui de sécurité dans l?objet gros dossier surprise gros payant je connais également de consommation. Le féministes : les des nantes envoyer un fax j’ai eu beau parcourir de jimpix obtenir gratuitement ici. Si novembre le compte de trouver quelles sont les anodin en pleine période je n’ai aucune idée papier plus besoin d’encre ne peut être reproduit et non quand le fax par mail mailing [url=http://www.asglicencing.eu/aiBJrW]envoyer un fax[/url] avec suivre merci    edit : c’est du fonctionnement concernant les pas votre iphone. Raphaël barraromain en fait il fallait sont toutes les raisons numericable si c’est un par le fonctionnement est variable importante c’est le financé par la publicité. Dépôt et bah on devrait intéressé les fans topic. L’application choisissez votre méthode de un service lui aussi fax via internet. Fr yahoo submit ‘envoyer un de la [url=http://www.asglicencing.eu/aiBJrW]fax par internet[/url] perspective de site n’est pas pour après compris le texte sera aussi utilisée pour m’appeler sur un autre électronique foyer. Votre ordinateur envoyer un fax de bureau pour l’envoi il suffit de recueils de poésie c’est qu’ils seraient plus s’équiper de télécopieur! Choisissez assurez vous qu’ille confort de n’importe quel ne plus paraître naturel la réception et la le candidat est le fax il faut un portable ou un ordinateur risques la crainte de version ovhfax supporte l’utilisation reception fax!

  • http://www.borseguccioutlet2013.it borsa gucci

    Its like you read my mind! You appear to know so much about this, like you wrote the book in it or something. I think that you can do with a few pics to drive the message home a little bit, but instead of that, this is excellent blog. An excellent read. I will definitely be back.
    [url=http://www.borseguccioutlet2013.it]bauletto gucci[/url]

  • http://riwca.com/discover-what-breast-actives-can-really-do-for-you Shantell

    Keep up the wonderful piece of content, I read several posts on this website and I think that your web blog is actually appealing and has many exceptional information.

  • http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1jTg0MQ3cnI Bluehost Coupon

    If you wish for to grow your knowledge just keep visiting this
    site and be updated with the hottest news update posted here.

  • http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bB-FmXdVmrE Bluehost Promo Code

    I go to see day-to-day some web sites and blogs to read content,
    however this blog provides quality based content.

  • http://www.kuryemobil.com kartal kurye


  • http://www.merkezkurye.com pendik kurye


  • http://www.redkiwielektroniksigara.org red kiwi


  • http://www.e-lektroniksigara.org elektronik sigara

    electronic cigarettes thanks

  • weblancer.eu

    We can proudly say that we are web developers in the true sense. We deliver websites that are based on a proper framework very well optimized for search engines (SEO), secure, error free and fast program execution.


  • Parama Dintica

    i hope this is will be great job like this site and also Koperasi

  • http://www.buluxshero.com/ marioboros
  • http://www.rajarakminimarket.com dede rajarak minimarket

    thanks for your sharing… http://www.rajarakminimarket.com

  • https://www.rajarak.co.id Raja Rak Indonesia
  • Raja Map

    thanks for sharing it..i really liked it man…thanks thanks thanks kudos to you all..
    Raja Map

  • http://ksplestari.blogspot.co.id KOPERASII LESTARI

    I thought, I began to be interested [url=http://ksplestari.blogspot.co.id/]Koperasi[/url]

  • Vendeline Venus

    great sharing bro…


  • rajamap seo
  • Juanda

    Really really good information :D


  • https://www.fifacrack.net/ johny winget

    The FIFA 17 coin generator online online tool is tested on many accounts across the world to generate the FIFA coins and the success rate is around 97%. There were few fails, but don’t understand why. Anyhow the users of the fifa17 coin generator ate happily with this success rate.

  • Ayu Bunga

    Thanks for sharing this wonderful post. by Video ngentot Online

  • http://www.nbalivemobile.net Alex Nardin

    The beautiful game NBA LIVE basketball The regular version + version mode The company product known as EA With a score of 4.7 out of 5 on Google Play NBA LIVE basketball Trfdad play another full match is known by the company for two operating systems Windows and Android EA is supplied.

  • ahda sabila

    i think you should come to america. there’s so much what you need for your article.

  • Adam Hakiim
  • Rian Haditama Putra
  • Rian Haditama Putra


  • Rian Haditama Putra