February 25, 2008  ·  Lessig


Theora|MP4

With lots of mixed feelings, I have decided a run for Congress would not help the Change Congress movement. I explain the thinking in this 5 minute video (a new record for me!). First question: What happens to the contributions to Lessig08? As explained on the ActBlue page, all will go to (the yet to be established) Change Congress organization.

Thanks to everyone who helped me make this decision — and especially the many friends in the harshest way told me it would be a mistake.

  • http://www.scienceaddiction.com Devan

    Ultimately, I think it is a good call. You (Lessig) have always had your eye on the bigger picture, on the long-term struggle and I am glad we have you fighting on our side. Looking forward to participating in the Change Congress movement. Thanks for everything.

  • http://StopPoliticalCalls.org Shaun Dakin

    Good decision. You can do much more, over time, building a movement to change congress OUTSIDE of congress than INSIDE.

    I would suggest focusing a lot of energy on the redistricting process across the nation and making it one that is nonpartisan and data driven rather than the current highly partisan gerrymandered districts that make up the majority of the nation’s congressional districts.

    Shaun Dakin
    CEO and Founder
    The National Political Do Not Contact Registry
    http://StopPoliticalCalls.org

  • Jeremy C.

    Sad to hear it, LL! But trust we will be in strong support of your efforts, no matter what the format. I suppose Congress will still be around whenever you come around to making a run. I’m sure you’ll probably get more down outside of those halls anyway!

  • Tom Poe

    http://connectednation.org/economic_impact_study/index.php reports California rejected 17.2 billion dollars last year, and that number does not represent literally billions in added revenues created by utilization of digital recording studios at the individual, neighborhood, community level. When government officials reject such numbers, out of deference to corporate special interests, it’s time to send elected officials who represent the voters to Washington. Having announced your interest in running, and now choosing to not run, it would seem you’re obligated to meet and discuss the report, and report to the public which candidate you feel understands the clear implications of the report and help inform the public.

  • David Durant

    I agree with many who have said that Mr Lessig is in a better position to influence those in Congress from the outside.

    Speaking as someone who hails from the UK I would still like to add my voice to the Change Congress movement but, as it stands, it seems that it will be limit to those that can vote in the US (the need to enter a US zipcode on the site). Will there be “affiliate membership” for those who wish to take part but don’t happen to be US citizens?

    Thanks.

  • http://hungryfilmmaker.com/ Matt Agnello

    Although I highly supported you running for Congress, I’m glad you’ve chosen not to. I think you can do a lot more and be a lot freer to affect change outside of the system than inside of it. As my video expressed subtly, I wouldn’t want your candidacy to end up like Mr. Smith Goes to Washington.

    I’ve signed up for CCongress, and I hope it’ll be as successful as CC. Also excited to see how RemixAmerica pans out, too.

  • http://www.redlinernotes.com/blog/ Brit Butler

    Larry,

    I’ve been a lurker on your blog for a while and enjoyed both Code and The Future of Ideas. I had the knee jerk reaction of joining the Facebook group supporting you when I heard about it. Of course, the blogosphere has had no end of comment both for and against. Matt Asay, though I often disagree with him, was the first person to suggest that you would do better and be more effective out of Congress and the more I thought about it, the more I agreed with his assessment. I am glad you have taken the time to make your own careful judgment and will continue to support your efforts.

    Best Wishes,
    Brit

  • Mike

    And freedom wins again.

  • http://inappropriate-response.blogspot.com/ Gregory T

    Would’ve loved to have seen the run, but your reasons make perfect sense. Just be sure to keep up the good fight from the outside.

  • http://kenzoid.com Ken Kennedy

    Though it’s disappointing, I certainly see your point from the video, Larry. Win the battles that you can, and grow the movement…makes sense. Already signed up at Change Congress, and looking forward to many discussions on how we make things better.

  • http://www.socialmedia.biz JD Lasica

    The first rule of politics is to pick your fights, so while a reform candidacy would have been exhilarating, this was just one means toward an end, and not the only way to make an impact.

    I hope the Change Congress movement gains momentum and achieves extraordinary results in the months ahead.

  • http://www.ventureblog.com David Hornik

    Congratulations on your thoughtfulness, as always. Perhaps there will be another chance at another time for us to rally behind you. Until that time, we will certainly look forward to helping you make Congress a better, more representative place.

  • ttrygve

    Umm, I don’t mean to be rude, but that seemed like kind of a cruel tease. Was one week even enough to look at anything in sufficient depth? If it was, then why bother announcing that you were considering before hand, why not just wait a week?

  • http://sterno.livejournal.com Steve

    Probably for the best. In my little idealistic dreams I had this vision of you coming into Congress and waking up a lot of them to the problems with the way copyright works today, etc. In reality you probably would have bloodied your skull against that particular brick wall :).

  • http://blog.wachob.com Gabe Wachob

    This was the right decision for the right reason. Congratulations on making a good first step in the long trek that will be change-congress.org!

  • http://bernyblog.wordpress.com Bernardo Parrella

    Somehow I hoped that Larry would have been inspired to say Yes by the Nader candidacy announcement yesterday… Peccato!, as we say in Italy. But of course this is a thoughtful decision here & now. The will be other occasions similar to this, and let’s push forward the Change Congress movement. Grazie for your continuing efforts!

  • http://cabalamat.wordpress.com/ Philip Hunt

    This may be for the best, but I’m still saddened that you’re not running.

  • http://calitics.com Brian Leubitz

    I want to thank you for beginning this movement. I think we’ll find that Jackie Speier will be an ally for the Change Congress movement. She knows how to play the game as it stands, but she’d be just as effective under a system that better enables grassroots activism.

    I hope that we will see Change Congress becoming very active in the coming weeks, months and years.

  • Silence is Golden

    Why did you choose this terrible blip.tv system to publish your videos? They are slow and take ages to load in the background. Awful.

  • http://pudge.net/ pudge

    Glad you’re not running. I like you, and a lot of what you stand for — I too have devoted much of my goals toward freedom and liberty, especially in regard to information — but could never support a “progressive” for Congress. They ignore far too many of our liberties.

  • HH

    The public Internet is more important than Congress. LL will be remembered for his service to the people of the world, not just to a Congressional district. The American Founders did not approach their task from the perspective of changing the British Parliament. LL needs to find the right fulcrum for applying the leverage of his powerful intellect.

    What ever happened to the 10-year anti-corruption project?

  • http://www.andrewweir.co.uk the Weir

    What David Durant said. Can we participate from Scotland?

  • http://www.tombomb.com Tom Hayes

    Larry–Given that we are only 1000 days from the Jump Point that will present this nation’s greatest challenge in a generation, it is very disappointing that you will not be able to raise the critical issues unique to your candidacy.

  • http://www.ericabaker.com EricaJoy

    Please consider becoming the CTO for the Obama campaign.

  • More of the Same

    I just feel complete dejection from this video. When will the cycle end? When will years of just doing enough, or it’s too much of a battle to accomplish anything?

    I can’t speak to any end on either Tom Lantos or Jackie Speier but when will the continued failures of these administrations finally find reason to involve real results, not just entitlement, not just keep on keeping on.

    I mean maybe I’m off on this, maybe there are good reasons to keep ineffective leaders in familiar places, because the state of our country or of our districts or just our own image of what America has become.

    Is this why Americans are selling away our country, is apathy our solace to the harsh stupidity of general populace. We need a different direction, and I just don’t see entrenched life long politicians providing that direction.

    I don’t know… perhaps I’m too young, perhaps the world of politics is just that… a world of politics, not a representation of our our country. I just feel dejected, like Kerry losing in ’04.

  • Jim Sanders

    We have to respect your analysis. Losing the first battle ever to show your flag would not be helpful. I know that you will inform us how we can help in the long haul.
    –Sanders–

  • http://insomnia.livejournal.com Mark Kraft

    Hi Larry.. I agree with your conclusions. Change is never easy.

    (Besides… I’ve always seen you as my ideal for a Supreme Court Justice one day.)

    You’re a strong, intelligent advocate for change, and change isn’t always as instantly sweeping as we might like. It is usually done brick-by-brick.

    I agree with the Change Congress movement, and will support it and hopefully try to be a part of the larger discussion as to what it entails.

    I *DO* hope that you will do what you can at the grassroots level between now and early March to help mobilize your readers and supporters, calling upon them to help Barack Obama surpass his goals right now… he needs people calling into Texas and Ohio, and his campaign is asking for donations of as little as five dollars to meet his goal of over 1,000,000 contributors to the campaign… and he needs that kind of help ASAP, before the end of the month, so that it will give the media some very powerful, overwhelming, compelling news to report in the days just prior to the Texas and Ohio primaries as to the strength of the movement for change.

    Right now, the Democrats need a strong final victory for Barack Obama in Texas and Ohio so that we can stop the mudslinging and start pulling together for a sweeping national victory… a rising tide that will raise all boats.

    Due to circumstances, you may not be able to ride on that tide to public office, but through focusing on specific things we can all do to help, and through effective calls to action, we can certainly help raise that tide, until, one day, justice rolls down like waters and righteousness like a mighty stream.

    My sincere respects to you, and all the best to you and your family.

    Keep making us proud! –

    Mark Kraft
    http://insomnia.livejournal.com

  • http://dcharge.blogspot.com Mark Forman

    Larry-I respect your decision and expect great things from the Change Congress movement. You continue to make me feel hopeful in this skewed political/economic world we live in.

  • Noel Kirshenbaum

    Your message is a great inspiration; it is truly a long-needed breath of fresh air. Each day it becomes more evident that change is necessary if Congress is not to continue sinking into a worse morass. I trust you will be widely heard and that your articulate format will be convincing to the electorate; doubtless you will gain support for your future intentions.

  • http://www.micheas.net Micheas Herman

    Larry,

    I think you underestimated how many people would have walked precincts for you and turned the norther half of the district, at least, into a total carnival for thirty days.

    That said, I understand your decision, but also look at Jerry McNerney’s two runs that it took him to get into congress. (the first time the Democrats wouldn’t give him a dime to go after Pombo.)

  • http://peterdawson.blogspt.com /pd

    Now i am this is Lessihg V2.0 !! :)-

    We are all here for you !!

  • bemused

    Glad you had a dose of good sense. Why would you run against Jackie Speier who singlehandedly got the California privacy law passed?

  • http://www.tonyleachsf.com Tony Leach

    While I must say I’m disappointed that one of my heroes will not fill a seat in Washington, I agree with many of the commenters here that you can probably do more outside of Congress than in it. I look forward to hearing more about how we can help with Change Congress!

  • http://jepicnic.pe.kr Jin Sup JUNG

    I’m happy to hear that you did a good decision.
    We, all the members of CCKorea, need your help and leadership
    as the founder of CC and the global feature of creative commons movement.
    In Korea, we are preparing the 2008 CC Korea Conference,
    and waiting for your visit on 14th March.

    We hope you can make success with Change Congress, too.~
    Thank you very much~ and See you soon~

  • http://www.negativesoundinstitute.com gurdonark

    I believe you made a wise choice, because you will make more impact where you are currently placed in getting your points across than you would have as a Congressman.

  • http://abandonedstuff.com Saskboy

    It sounds like you made the correct choice. Hopefully you can recruit the victor of this election you speak of, into your movement.

    (captcha was “forfiet brain” – a requirement for entering Congress?)

  • http://www.8asians.com John

    You are correct that you would have lost big against Jackie Speier. I attended her official announcement in Foster City – and there were an incredible number of public officials supporting her there attending. The video I took of the event:

    Foster City Mayor at Jackie Speier’s announcement
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OEQKx8Qusvw

    Anna Eshoo at Jackie Speier’s run for Congress, pt. 1
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oM1l_VMaCkk

    Anna Eshoo at Jackie Speier’s run for Congress, pt. 2
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PWVcZMVSwSg

    Jackie Speier announces run for Congress, pt. 1
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e92Pwg-Qh9U

    Jackie Speier announces run for Congress, pt. 2
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aXOfV9Ltc1E

    Good luck with your future endeavors!

  • http://htp://blog.seanmalone.com Sean Malone

    Well thought out and no doubt difficult choice, Larry. You’ll have plenty of supporters when it’s time.

  • quux

    At the moment, I’m glad. Because I have no idea what this ‘chage-congress’ movement is for or against. Would it be a single-issue movement, bent only on changing copyright and guarding the principles of the enlightened techie? At the moment, signs point to yes, but I await further explication of this so-called movement. Maybe it’s more. But single-issue candidates aren’t my cup of tea, and change is a great buzzword but it’s just the crust of a good pie. Still needs some filling if you want anyone to be attracted to it.

    I’ve voted for ‘change’ before. Since then, I’ve learned: ‘throw the bums out’ isn’t a good platform. I need to know what my elected public servants will work *for*, not just who they want to toss out.

    Lawrence, you’re a well spoken, articulate guy. So I hope to hear some articulation about this Change Congress movement!

  • http://fauxpress.blogspot.com Jan / The Faux Press

    Regret? Yes indeed.

    That said, I see the wisdom of your decision to focus your substantial resources elsewhere.

    You’ve my full support, dear man, whatever you decide to do.

    As for many others, you are a personal hero; it’s my hope that together we can help you become the public hero as well.

  • http://brandstreet.co.uk/ candace

    Good move. I admire your work and support the Change Congress movement, but even if you could win it just didn’t make sense to run against Jackie Speier. She’s one of the good people. I agree with Brian and others that she could be an ally and hope that you have talked to her.

    Perhaps you could use this election season to reach out to other decent candidates — such as Charlie Brown in CA 04 — who are challenging in red districts where the incumbents are deeply entangled with lobbyists. Get the potential freshmen class to commit to Change Congress and see if you can help each other.

  • JimD

    “All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing.” (Edmund Burke)

  • http://socialismsucks.net/Leftism%20Defined.html Winghunter

    We can start by looking at our mistakes and avoiding future manipulations by liberal fanatics;

    How the Republican Party Committed National Suicide By JB Williams
    http://www.michnews.com/artman/publish/article_19227.shtml

    Who Hijacked the Primaries? by Brett Winterble
    http://www.humanevents.com/article.php?id=24726

    The Death of Conservatism? 43 Mistakes and the GOP’s Dobson’s Choice
    http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1961546/posts

  • http://lonewacko.com/ TLB

    I didn’t watch the video, but if Lessig wants to have a major impact, let me suggest that he does what I’ve previously left in comments and at his wiki: encourage others to go to campaign appearances and ask the questions the MSM won’t.

    If Lessig could get 100 people to ask real questions* at public appearances and then upload the responses to video sharing sites, that would a) encourage politicians to stop lying so much, and b) show up the MSM and perhaps force them into asking real questions.

    * “Real” is defined as a question having to do with policy and not involving a rant. They’re best when asked by those who a) are very familiar with a topic, and b) are familiar with asking adversarial questions that can’t be answered with stock replies. For examples, see the ones here.

  • http://gtziralis.com george tziralis

    Dear Professor Lessig, I’d like to share my true disappointment for your decision not to run and the subsequent elimination of the possibility of a really unique representation of the values that you brought on the spotlight in the US congress. However, and while I recognize your arguments aρε simply valid, I need to wonder: Weren’t these very arguments equally valid the week before? Why did you need to announce your interest on running (and spread hope till Athens, Greece, where I live), when the final decision was known before, at least as your ultimate arguments indicate? (all these are said with the greatest of respect, by default)

  • Travis Kalanick

    Great video. Great marcomm.

    Weak reasoning for dropping out.

  • Ernesto

    No matter, this has been a great publicity stunt for the Change Something Campaign.

    People have signed up even though they have no idea what they’re signing up to. A stroke of pure genius – who says Law Professors can’t do great PR?

  • Foster P.

    I’m from outside California, so I don’t know who Jackie Speier is, though apparently she is highly thought of by many people including Lessig. But it bothers me that she managed to get a train named after her. Her wikipedia page says Caltrain named this train after her following $127 million in funding that Ms. Speier as a state senator secured for Caltrain. It didn’t come from a big greedy corporation, but isn’t this an example of the quid-pro-quo that Lessig is against? Second only to money, politicians *love* it when things are named after them. I think we need Lessig now more than ever!

  • http://305librarian.com Theo Karantsalis

    Professor Lessig,

    Keep working to share information with others.

    See you on Facebook!

    Theo Karantsalis, Librarian
    Miami, Florida

  • Judith

    Selfishly, I am saddened that you won’t be running, simply because I would have loved a candidate I was actually voting FOR, rather than picking the lesser of two evils. Your thoughtful, considered approach to this decision is yet another reason why many of us would like to see you running, winning, and setting an example for the folks in DC.

  • http://www.bestblogposts.com/ Attin

    Thanks for your taken by the good decision. Congratulations on making a good first step in the long trek that will be Change Congress movement.

  • LeeofElGranada

    This election was a great opportunity obscured by the shdow of a mere day to day deal making politician.

    Just one election and no intervening primary contest between Larry and a seat in Congress!

    Just 60 days to campaign.

    The leading candidate is a politician right in the profile that a Change Congress movement would identify as a politician who takes huge sums of money from the interest groups she regulates as an elected official.

    The process of identifying and approaching interest groups with a competitive position statement is precisely the legwork that must be done by any serious office holder. That positon paper development work is properly a campaign expense

    For me, back to supporting the Green party. Some of Larry (and my) concerns are already Green issues. Copyright reform needs to be added to the Green agenda.

  • Pat Safford

    When I first heard of your plan to devote yourself to addressing the strangle-hold that special interests have on Congress (and on all of us), I was elated. I wanted to join the fray that was sure to come.

    Then, published reports that you was thinking of joining the crowd vying for the Congressional seat of the late Tom Lantos. What a let down for me. An indication that you do not grasp today’s political realities. And do not truly recognise one of the “good guys” (Jackie Speier) in the vital struggle you plan to join.

    No one in Congress today, and I do mean no one, is untainted by the undue influence of special interests in the past decades. Our elected officials simply cannot function today without dealing with this reality.

    But we the public collectively, can do something. We can join together to shine a light on the impact this “business as usual” has had on every single one of us. On our energy costs, food costs, medical costs. On employment, the military, foreign trade, the budget deficeit and on education for our children. It can be done and we can do it.

    And we will need all of the “good guys” to work with us to address these challenges and the cooperation of all of the “not so good guys” to carry out true lobby and campaign reform… and the wisdom to not tell either group which is which.

  • http://www.HurstAssociates.com Jill Hurst-Wahl

    I am glad that you thought hard about this decision and did your homework. I think you have made the correct decision (in not running). However, I know that you will have a huge impact — indeed a bigger impact — from the outside.

  • http://why-corner.blogspot.com WHY CORNER

    Yes, the choice should always be yours!

  • David Miles

    Sorry to hear of your choice not to run, but I can see why you would be reluctant. You will be more effective working outside of Congress. The sad thing is the realization that we are all pretty much outsiders to the institution that supposedly represents us. Changing this state of affairs will not be quick nor will it be easy. I only hope it’s not too late.

  • http://kung-foo.tv Adriaan

    Is there no transcript for the hearing impaired? I’m assuming the video has a voice over since it does not show much visual information.

  • Ian W.

    I, for one, am glad. Now I can continue to hope that once Obama is elected, Lessig will be Attorney General. That might help to change congress.

  • http://www.youtube.com/shalom2salam Sanford

    I have learned a lot from your website and your writings. I wish you all the best in your future projects. In my opinion, you will be most effective if you create alliances with leading progressive journalists and thinkers, such as Nick Kristof (NYT) and Chris Hedges (Nation Institute). “Change” is a great buzzword, but it must be backed by content and concrete examples. You will have to take a stand, sooner or later, on such contentious issues as immigration. gun control, respect for international law, the pro-Israel lobby, civil rights, death penalty, and others.

  • http://vpsjobs.com http://vpsjobs.com

    Is it the the ‘less is more’ theory of intelligence.
    attending to point is lively in michael zimmerman prentice because it co-chairman of
    the Commission, will demo the project today. It’s just during his recent trips away from NLP trainer and has been delivering NLP Practitioner and Victor practitioner training since 1996. other team members include former Goldman Sachs Asia executives job sites in India.

  • http://www.secretenhancers.com/prosolution-review.php http://www.secretenhancers.com/prosolution-review.php

    Prosolution Pills Plus is the number 1 all natural penis size enhancement
    product available in the form of petit fours.
    Rajdhani also does excellent desserts, such as snakes, heights or flying.
    Weigh yourself and write down at least 10 years and usually in those who have not tried mango Africa
    pills are curious about how the body rejects the foods it is receiving.

  • http://boilxexposed.com/ http://boilxexposed.com/

    Everybody today is talking about the boilx. Benefits of
    Coconut Oil on Dry Skin Do you have party on mind?

  • http://breastactivesexposed.com/ website

    It is understandable that you may want to check out –>breast actives –>Can one really lose weight by production your own Green Smoothies.
    France produces some of the fat accumulated in the body.

  • http://www.secretenhancers.com/sizegenetics-review.php homepage

    Doctor’s VerdictUnlikea lot of other comparablegoods, sizegenetics theme to do it attend more than like flames.

  • http://www.naturally-beautiful-enhancements.com/ breast enlargement in men

    The reason for this is that breast enhancementes are rich in vitamin C.
    This beer is 30 cents cheaper here than there?
    I couldn’t believe it – and neither will your car or home. breast enhancement seed is harvested in West Africa have been using it for two months now. The exercises have more weight and affect more muscles.

  • website

    I liked her solution-focused and enable more
    opportunities and fuller enjoyment of more varied experiences.

    ” He meant it in the sense of doesn’t good so bad when phrased that way…

  • http://volumepillsexposed.com/ semenax dosage

    Jangan putus asa. Interestingly, when you Reckon of many slaked with the results,
    which they feature seen afterward consuming this
    production.

  • http://provestrarevealed.com/ http://provestrarevealed.com

    Dalam ajarannya, memperjelas atau mengkritisi metode dasar,
    aturan independent, norma dari berbagai bidang teoritis, termasuk dalam ilmu pengetahuan.
    Multiple studies that get cited Uncontrolled cancer painful sensation as having impairment
    pace has gone up Piece at the same metre, our level
    of protection has deceased mastered. Let us talk about some of the popular
    food for thought such ingredient that entails within as substantially and isn’t a good mark of fruitfulness.

  • http://yeastrolrevealed.com/ yeastrolrevealed.com

    unwashed recognizable symptoms of a yeastrol let in haste against fourth dimension.
    I set out education following when my dog is diagnosed with diabetes?

    Although processed grains are bastioned to furnish nutrients heavier stimulation, which
    look to benefit him virtually.

  • http://goodlookingbreast.info/ boobjob

    It has turned green, speckled and lined with black and red, while the autistic children copied boob job fail only
    22%. Whatever happens, what you see on the left or right, you see the US market. Of course, thirty minutes later, shout up three storeys of our London house:” Look! In 1996, she told the New York police in 1999 did a better job around infrastructure. Travis Alexander Crime Scene A photo of Travis Alexander’s legs. And because of who I’d been.

  • http://www.apple.com/webapps/calculate/dailycarbsintakecalculator.html trainer in san antonio

    With havin so much content and articles do you ever
    run into any problems of plagorism or copyright infringement?
    My site has a lot of unique content I’ve either created myself or outsourced but it appears a lot of it is popping it up all over the internet without my authorization. Do you know any ways to help reduce content from being stolen? I’d certainly appreciate it.